Sometimes an excellent operating system can be made even better
Alcatel A3 XL phone: Full, in-depth review
A sub-$200 6-inch Android smartphone? How cheap is too cheap?
- Very cheap
- Good big screen
- Good stills camera
- Good speaker
- Front camera is mediocre
- Responsiveness is below average
It's just $179 and yet we struggled to criticise this 6" Android smartphone. Enthusiasts will find it a bit slow, but cash-strapped casual users will love it.
Price$ 179.00 (AUD)
[Update: Our initial review of this phone used a review model with old software (and some lesser hardware) that was particularly slow and laggy. We've since used an updated model and found that things were much improved. The overall score has increased accordingly.]
We’ve been flooded with new phones over recent months and the differences have all been relatively minor. But now here’s Alcatel with a six-inch smartphone that makes the $300 Moto G5 look expensive. But how cheap is too cheap?
6in, 720 x 1280 (245ppi) LCD screen, 2GB/16GB RAM, 1.1GHz quad-core A53 CPU, Mali-T720MP2 GPU, 8MP rear and 5MP front cameras, microSD, microSIM, Micro USB, Android 7, 3000mAh battery, 165 x 83 x 8mm, 145g. Full specs here.
Design and Handling
We don’t expect too much at this price but the A3 XL still punches above its weight. The front screen with its rounded corners looks similar to most other phones and the textured, grey back looks business-like. It doesn’t look like a cheap phone.
The six-inch screen gets bright and colours are impressively vibrant. While the 720p HD resolution is down on many rivals and the relatively-large size means that there are only 245 pixels per inch, at least icons and text appear larger than usual which will be a boon for those who are fed up of squinting at the minuscule lettering of small, Ultra HD screens.
The Operating System is a basic Android 7 and is simple enough to use. But it doesn’t take long for the limitations of the 1.1GHz quad-core processor to rear their head. Basic apps can take a moment or two longer to open than we've been used to and responsiveness is a bit low compared to the rest of the market. Loading mail apps can take an extra second or two but scrolling through them is fast enough.
A high-end, computationally-demanding game like Need For Speed No Limits takes an age to load but the well-optimised coding meant that it was still playable albeit with a few frame drops. Dropping down to Angry Birds, loading times were a bit slower than usual but not by much and the game was very playable. Pokemon Go (with its new gym update) took a long time to load up. It can be a bit juddery and laggy at times but it’s very playable.
There’s a fingerprint reader on the back which is an impressive feature at this price. However, it’s not the fastest or most reliable unit we’ve seen. It frequently took a few attempts to recognise our finger but at least the feature is there and you don’t have to use it.
All in all, we were impressed. An early version of the software on this phone led us to believe it was annoyingly slow and laggy but really, while it's not as responsive as more-expensive models, it's still usable for most smartphone applications (forget about VR though!)
We were actually impressed with the speakers. Regular phone quality was decent and conference calls were loud and clear – more so than some pricier rivals.
Playing our treble-rich test track, Bjork’s Play Dead, demonstrated an impressive amount of volume, clarity and even a little punch – despite an almost complete lack of bass. Indeed, performance here exceeded many top phones.
Switching to the bass heavy Army of Me, we were again greeted with an impressively-rounded and loud sound despite the lack of bass. We should also note that the speaker is located on the back and sound is much better when turning the phone over and listening to it that way rather than it bouncing off a table or whatever.
Ultimately, though the Arkamys-optimised speaker does a very good job compared to any phone at any price.
Alcatel A3 XL camera review
The main camera is only 8-megapixels but it’s capable of sharp and colourful pictures in good lighting – up close and at distance.
Read more: Kogan Agora 8 phone: Full, in-depth review
Things can fall off a cliff in low light but even so, some mediocre-lit indoors shots still came out usable. In the dark though, there’s not much to see.
Panoramas are just about acceptable but you wouldn’t want to print them out. They’re low resolution and some lighting blending transitions can be verge on harsh.
Landscapes looked better with HDR but using this did mean there was a few seconds wait while image processing occurred.
Selfies were a mixed bag. The front camera is only 5-megapixels and it’s not great in low light per se. However, there's a small LED flash that can make up for mediocre lighting. This can also make you look a little palid but Beauty Mode can add some colour to those cheeks (if required) without making you look ridiculously airbrushed. Nonetheless, many of our shots came out looking soft or had colour casts. It's not the best phone for Narcissists.
Video is captured at 720p (HD). It’s naturally a bit fuzzy on high resolution screens and gets grainier when in low light. It’s poor in very low light and background noise can be sound a bit robotic. But for undemanding users it was all still (just about) usable. It helps if lighting is good and everyone is still, though.
Next: Battery Life and Conclusion
Join the newsletter!
Most Popular Reviews
- 1 Samsung Galaxy Watch review: Brilliant but not quite a breakthrough
- 2 HP Omen 15 (2018): Full, in-depth review
- 3 HP Envy x360 13 (Ryzen): Full, in-depth review
- 4 Dell G5 review: Easy to live with
- 5 D-Link Omna 180 Cam HD DSH-C310 review
Latest News Articles
- Ring expand local offering with new Stick Up Cam
- Huawei Matebook X Pro review: Homecoming King
- Android Q details leaked
- Hands on: The Kensington SD7000 dock turns a Surface tablet into a Surface Studio
- PCWorld is streaming Atlas on Twitch and YouTube!
PCW Evaluation Team
Microsoft Office continues to make a student’s life that little bit easier by offering reliable, easy to use, time-saving functionality, while continuing to develop new features that further enhance what is already a formidable collection of applications
I’d recommend a Dell XPS 15 2-in-1 and the new Windows 10 to anyone who needs to get serious work done (before you kick back on your couch with your favourite Netflix show.)
It’s useful for office tasks as well as pragmatic labelling of equipment and storage – just don’t get too excited and label everything in sight!
The Brother MFC-L8900CDW is an absolute stand out. I struggle to fault it.
I need power and lots of it. As a Front End Web developer anything less just won’t cut it which is why the MSI GT75 is an outstanding laptop for me. It’s a sleek and futuristic looking, high quality, beast that has a touch of sci-fi flare about it.
If you’re looking to invest in your next work horse laptop for work or home use, you can’t go wrong with the MSI GE63.
- CES 2019 Round-Up:
- Razer Phone 2 review: One for the fans
- Samsung’s Galaxy S10 will launch on Feb 20
- Which flagship TV is best? Sony 4K HDR Bravia 2016 versus LG 4K HDR OLED 2016
- 10 Blu-ray movies / Best looking Blu-ray movies