Huawei MediaPad M5 Pro vs. Apple iPad: A premium Android tablet takes on the leader
- 26 July, 2018 20:30
When we're talking about tablets, there are basically two markets: Apple's iPads and everything else. But in the everything-else bucket, there are a couple of standouts, and the Huawei MediaPad M5 Pro is certainly one of them.
With a 10.8-inch screen, stylus support, and a Pogo pin connector for attaching a keyboard along with a $449 price tag, Huawei is targeting both the 10.5-inch iPad Pro and the latest 9.7-inch iPad with the MediaPad M5 Pro. So is this the affordable pro tablet Android users have been waiting for? Let's see how it stacks up against Apple's newest tablet.
MediaPad M5 Pro vs 9.7-inch iPad: Price
Let's start at the most important part: the price. At first glance, it seems like the 9.7-inch iPad is actually the better bargain:
- MediaPad M5 Pro: $449
- 9.7-inch iPad: $329
- 10.5-inch iPad Pro: $649
But there are some caveats. Huawei includes its M-Pen in the box, while Apple charges $99 for the Pencil. Also the MediaPad M5 Pro has support for LTE, which costs an additional $129 on the iPad. So things change when you match the iPads to what's included with the M5 Pro:
- MediaPad M5 Pro (includes stylus and LTE support): $449
- 9.7-inch iPad (adding $99 stylus and $129 LTE support): $558
- 10.5-inch iPad Pro (adding $99 stylus and $129 LTE support): $878
Plus the MediaPad has 64GB of storage—the same as you get on the iPad Pro and twice that of the 9.7-inch iPad—along with a microSD slot for expandable storage. Granted it might be too much tablet for some people, but if you need the LTE, storage, and stylus, the MediaPad M5 Pro is easily the better value.
Winner: MediaPad M5 Pro
MediaPad M5 Pro vs iPad: Design
You don't need to be a tablet expert to see the most obvious difference between the MediaPad M5 Pro and the iPad: their outer dimensions. While the 10.8-inch MediaPad M5 Pro has a screen that's nearly the same diagonal width as the 10.5-inch display on the iPad Pro, the MediaPad display's super-wide 16:9 aspect ratio and broader bezels make the tablet noticeably longer and narrower than the iPad, with its 4:3 display. Here are their exact measurements:
- MediaPad M5 Pro: 274.3 x 171.8 x 7.4mm
- 9.7-inch iPad: 240 x 169.5 x 7.5mm
- 10.5-inch iPad Pro: 250.6 × 174.1 × 6.1 mm
It's not just that it's bigger. While it actually looks and feels far thinner than it actually is, the MediaPad's elongated size makes it a bit awkward to use, particularly in portrait mode. When holding it in landscape mode, however, the 2.5D (curved-edge) glass and chamfered edges rest nicely in your hand. The MediaPad M5 Pro comes in one color scheme—gold with a white front—where Apple offers more options, with silver, space gray (with a black front) and rose gold—but overall, Huawei has built a tablet that feels just as premium as the iPad.
The bezel designs are also distinctive because of design choices. The iPad has a thick bottom bezel to accommodate its circular home button, but its side bezels are thinner. An oval-shaped home button means the MediaPad M5 Pro can have a smaller chin than either iPad has. Huawei's decision to make the bezels the same thickness, however, makes the tablet look a little clunkier on the sides. It's a tradeoff that I didn't love (plus I could have done without the Huawei logo in the center of the top bezel).
Around the back, the two tablets look strikingly similar, with some notable exceptions. Like the iPad, the MediaPad M5 Pro's back panel houses a 13MP camera in the top right corner with a sizable bump, while Apple's is on the left. Otherwise, the M5's back is just as clean as the iPad. A pair of long grilles along the top and bottom edges house four speakers, similar to the iPad Pro. There's no headphone jack, but it comes with a USB-C-to-3.5mm adapter. The USB-C port is oddly positioned at the far left of the edge below the home button, which is also where you'll find the power button and volume rocker, which take some getting used to. In contrast, Apple keeps it simple with the 9.7-inch iPad: There's a Lightning port and speaker grille on the bottom and a headphone jack at the top.
But the real difference is with orientation. While Apple's tablets skew toward portrait mode, the company's mostly content to let the user decide which way to hold the iPad. Huawei, on the other hand, clearly wants you to use the MediaPad M5 Pro in landscape mode. The home button might beckon you to pick it up in portrait mode, everything else about it is made for wide-screen use, from the placement of the selfie camera and the logo, to the buttons and screen ratio. It's a nice design, but holding the M5 Pro in portrait mode for any extended amount of time is seriously awkward.
MediaPad M5 Pro vs iPad: Display
Despite the wider presentation on the MediaPad M5, both tablets have similar Retina-worthy resolutions:
- MediaPad M5 Pro: 2560 x 1600
- 9.7-inch iPad: 2048 x 1536
The iPad and MediaPad M5 Pro both use IPS-like display technology, and it's hard to spot much of a difference between them. The iPad Pro's True Tone display and ProMotion feature stand alone and add an extra element in certain lighting and situations, but when comparing it with the 9.7-inch iPad, the overall clarity and brightness on the MediaPad is superior to my eyes. Colors popped without being oversaturated. Even at full brightness, I was able to use it for long amounts of time without straining my eyes. The wide screen makes a real difference when watching movies.
Winner: MediaPad M5 Pro
MediaPad M5 Pro vs iPad: Performance and battery
Both tablets use homegrown processors rather than Qualcomm's popular Snapdragon chips. The MediaPad M5 Pro gets a special "s" version of Huawei's last-gen Kirin 960 octa-core chip. Curiously, it's actually slower than the original chip, running at 2,100MHz rather than 2,400MHz, so I suspect the tweak has more to do with power efficiency than performance.
As such, battery life is also stellar. The MediaPad M5 Pro includes a massive 7,500mAh battery that lasts for several days of normal use. Huawei rates it for 12 hours of 1080p video playback (two hours longer than the 10-hour iPad), and you'll definitely be able to squeeze in a more after a full day of heavy work. I consistently had more battery left on the MediaPad after performing two simultaneously draining tasks. More importantly, I didn't encounter any of the tell-tale lag that so often afflicts Android tablets. If given the choice, I'd rather the MediaPad had used the Mate 10 Pro's Kirin 970 processor, which brings AI processing and superior power efficiency, but the 960s seems more than capable of handling moderate tasks.
Apple's 9.7-inch iPad also runs a previous-generation A10 Fusion chip, but the speed differences are minimal between it and the newer A10X Fusion chip in the iPad Pro. Thanks to iOS optimizations, apps and animations fly on Apple's iPads long after their shelf life has expired. It remains to be seen if Huawei's chip can stand up to years of use. Benchmark scores skewed heavily in favor of the iPad, but out of the box, both are more than capable of handling a healthy dose of work and play.
Winner (performance): iPad
Winner (battery): MediaPad M5 Pro
MediaPad M5 Pro vs iPad: OS and apps
The MediaPad M5 Pro runs an older version of Android Oreo (8.0 rather than the newer 8.1), but you still get the best features, including picture-in-picture and notification dots. Like its phones, Huawei skins Android with its own EMUI interface, but it's much more palatable on the larger screen. There are a few bloatware apps (Booking.com, Facebook, etc.), extra Huawei apps (HiCare, Kids Corner), and unnecessary Android duplicates (Email, Gallery). For the most part, however. Huawei's OS is well suited for the larger screen. And like the Mate 10 Pro, the M5 has a fantastic lock screen that displays a rotating series of gorgeous images.
The bigger issue is the apps. While Apple's App Store is crammed with apps, games, and utilities that take full advantage of the iPad's large screen in either orientation, Android developers have yet to fully embrace the tablet experience. As a result, most of the apps on the MediaPad M5 Pro feel like blown-out phone apps rather than powerful tablet ones. Even Google's apps are lacking the big-screen polish of Apple's, and the experience suffers as a result.
One of the biggest reasons for Android tablets' struggles is that the OS never embraced the possibilities, and that hasn't gotten any better with Oreo. From the gestures to the multitasking, everything on the iPad feels more powerful and intuitive. Using it side-by-side with a 2018 Android tablet only highlights how far behind Google's OS is.
The pen is mighty! Read on for a comparison of the Apple Pencil and Huawei M-Pen styli, camera, and more.
MediaPad M5 Pro vs iPad: M-Pen and Apple Pencil
The biggest selling point for all of these tablets is support for an active stylus. While you don't need a stylus to enjoy either device, they definitely enhance the experience.
The Apple Pencil and Huawei M-Pen are both powered styluses, which gives them unique abilities, but they work in different ways. Apple's Pencil is a Bluetooth device, so it needs to be paired to the iPad first, while Huawei's M-Pen has capabilities that work with the tablet without pairing (mainly, a button near the bottom will activate screenshot drawing mode). Despite the extra step, Apple's method is remarkably quick, though, and merely requires plugging the Pencil into the iPad's Lightning port. Both devices let you use the stylus for basic navigation, though I preferred the softer tip of the M-Pen to Apple's more rigid Pencil.
When it comes to charging, both styli have on-device ports. The Pencil connects via Lighting cable to draw power from the iPad itself (which is a little precarious) and the M-Pen's USB-C port is tucked under its built-in clip. Neither has a power button. Huawei claims its pen lasts for a whopping 50 days, while the Pencil will need a charge after about 12 hours. However, Apple's Pencil charges incredibly fast, taking just 15 seconds to slurp enough juice for 30 minutes of work.
Both styli are best suited for drawing rather than writing, and they perform well. Gliding either pen across the screen produces smooth lines with low latency. The M-Pen's 4096-level pressure sensitivity offers precise strokes and shadings.
It's hard to pick a winner based on performance alone (especially because I'm not an artist). I slightly preferred the size and weight on the M-Pen, which is closer to a ballpoint pen's feel than Apple's slightly elongated Pencil. Another M-Pen advantage is the MediaPad's bundled Nebo for Huawei app, which is a M-Pen-optimized version of its $6 Play Store and App Store note-taking app. The app is specifically built for stylus support, and its handwriting recognition is surprisingly good. The experience is basically the same as it is on the iPad, but it's nice not to have to pay for it on the MediaPad.
Winner: MediaPad M5 Pro
MediaPad M5 Pro vs iPad: Camera
Neither of these tablets will be spending much time in the camera app, but the MediaPad M5 Pro's wider form factor actually makes it a little easier to snap pics. The MediaPad also has the better camera on paper (13MP vs. 8MP on the iPad and 12MP on the iPad Pro), but your shots aren't going to win any awards. Basically pictures from all these tablets look like they were taken with 2014 phones, with fuzzy edges, terrible low-light graininess, and an overall lack of sharpness.
Huawei's app is a bit more robust than Apple's, with a set of manual controls and a cool light-painting mode that lets you create long-exposure effects. But that doesn't necessarily mean you'll take better shots. Given how stellar the cameras are on both the iPhone and Huawei's Mate 10 Pro, it's a bummer that their respective tablet cousins are so underwhelming in the photography department. The good news is you'll probably have a really good phone in your pocket when it's time to take a picture.
MediaPad M5 Pro vs iPad: PC replacement
While Huawei isn't running any snarky "What's a computer?" ads to promote the MediaPad M5 Pro, it clearly wants you at least to consider using its tablet as a PC. A trio of Pogo pins lets you attach a keyboard, which Huawei sells separately, a feature reserved for the more expensive iPad Pro.
Pop a MediaPad M5 Pro into the keyboard and it'll instantly switch into PC Mode, turning the home screen into more of a desktop, with resizable windows and a dock. It's similar to what Huawei does with its Mate 10 Pro, but the MediaPad doesn't support USB-C-to-HDMI, so you can't expand the screen with a monitor. It's odd that Huawei would limit the feature to its phonesespecially because tablets are more designed for heavy workbut I guess it's designed to sell more keyboards. As such, it's still closer to a PC environment than anything you'll get with the iPad, which really only adds keyboard shortcuts when a Smart Keyboard is attached.
When used as a straight tablet, both offer split-screen multitasking and picture-in-picture support. The iPad has better app support and a slicker implementation overall, but both apps handle split-screen multitasking well. The iPad's app advantage is once again on display here, however, as there are more apps that are optimized for the multi-window view.
Winner (with keyboard): Huawei MediaPad M5 Pro
Winner (without keyboard): iPad
Should I buy a Huawei MediaPad M5 Pro or an iPad?
While the decision to buy an iPhone or an Android phone pretty much starts and ends at the ecosystem, it's less of an issue when buying a tablet. While the iPhone-iPad continuity features are nice, they're not central to the experience. Android users can happily incorporate an iPad into their existing mobile workflow with things like Google apps and Dropbox.
But Huawei has made a strong reason to consider an Android tablet. The stylus, display, and keyboard support are closer to Apple's iPad Pro than its $449 price tag would indicate, and its cellular connectivity and specs are a steal for the price. If Huawei added support for PC Mode with an USB-C-to-HDMI cable in a future update it would seal the deal.
For now, the iPad's app support and OS swing the pendulum just a bit in its favor, but I'm comfortable saying the Huawei MediaPad M5 Pro is one of the best tablets you can buy.