Searching for Bing: How Microsoft's search engine has lost its way

Yes, Bing still searches for porn. But in several other aspects, its quality has declined.

In 2015, Microsoft’s Bing search engine achieved something it had never had before: relevancy. By notching a 20-percent share of U.S. search, according to comScore, it managed to impact Google, the brand that was literally synonymous with search. 

In 2018, it seems like Bing’s willing to hand some of that success right back. Why? Because, as a habitual Bing user, I’ve noticed a deterioration in quality.

In the past I’ve argued that there were four good reasons to switch from Google to Bing.  Since then, I’ve used Bing extensively, and it still remains my PC’s default search engine. I’ve sold colleagues on the benefits of Microsoft Rewards. Like anyone else, I’ve used Bing to hunt down news, search for social media posts on Twitter and elsewhere, research queries and trips, and more. But on more and more occasions, I find myself typing in Google.com within the search bar, then hunting down some tidbit or story that I know is there.

Granted—and this is important—this is a subjective viewpoint, and cherry-picking specific queries is just that, cherry-picking. But there are certain areas where I think Bing has either deteriorated or simply doesn’t measure up to Google. Here are a few examples.

News search gets lost

Consider the same search on Bing and Google: “ThinkPad,” Lenovo’s iconic notebook series. As a journalist, I often click on the “news” tab of both search engines, with the idea that I want to see relevant news from both search engines, typically referred to as Google News and Bing News.

Immediately there are stark differences between the two. Bing News shows me just three results. Not only is it wasted space, but Google, by comparison, clusters several recent stories together. 

thinkpad Mark Hachman / IDG

Google is far superior to Bing in terms of information density, as far as news is concerned. 

Bing favors the sort of “endlessly scrolling” Web page design that eliminates unnecessary page clicks, a point in its favor. But just three entries down is a “trending on Bing” carousel with world news and politics, and nothing about the ThinkPad. That’s not what I’m looking for! Google News requires a click to jump to the next page, but everything appears relevant. When I first started researching this story a few weeks ago, Bing showed me an Atlanta crime story where a ThinkPad just happened to be one of the items stolen from a vehicle.

Generic searches for news stories also demonstrate stark differences between the two search engines. I frequently use search engines to research (and link) older stories. Entering “hachman snapdragon 850 pcworld” brings up the result I’m looking for within Google; in Bing, it doesn’t even appear on the first page of results. That’s a fundamental misstep, and one I’d swear wasn’t there several months ago.

hachman snapdragon 850 pcworld Mark Hachman / IDG

For me, this is one of Bing’s big weaknesses: my inability to find stories I know exist, but can’t find.

Bing seems to be moving in the direction of providing multiple sources or opinions to confirm reports. But from my standpoint, it’s failing at its basic goal: providing relevant links.

What happened to searching social networks?

At one point, Bing touted itself as the destination for social search, with a sidebar and various tools to connect to social networks. These days it has trouble keeping up with Google.

Consider the following search, where I wanted to see what the reactions had been to legendary announcer Don Criqui’s receiving the ax as the radio voice of my alma mater, University of Notre Dame (“Twitter Don Criqui”).

twitter don criqui Mark Hachman / IDG

Bing offers up some inaccurate results, and generally ignores Twitter search. Google does a better job.

While Twitter would like you to believe that the best Twitter search lives on Twitter.com, Bing sort of flubs the whole thing outside of the lead result. Google at least gives you a decent effort. (Unfortunately, neither Bing nor Google can provide anything besides Criqui’s Facebook page.)

Image searches are hit-and-miss

One of the historical strengths of Bing is its image-search capabilities, which I revisited to see how the search engine is doing. It’s easy enough to pull up images of actress Nicole Kidman, even when the search is “Nicole Kidman at age 23.” (Though does Google pull up more images of a younger Kidman? Perhaps.) But what both Google and Bing are touting today is the intelligence of their search engines: How specific can they be? Here, Google pulls ahead: try “a snowy lake at night” and “a hat in a field.” While both Bing and Google nail the first, Bing fails badly at the second.

a hat in a field Mark Hachman / IDG

I’m not sure what’s going on here, but Bing’s image search isn’t demonstrating much intelligence.

Generally, both Bing and Google do well when asked to search for images that you know already exist: “Marilyn Monroe and Groucho Marx,” for example, or celebrities in general: “DMX and puppy.” But again, if you’re asking Bing and Google for images that are (probably) being identified by AI, rather than metadata, Google seems to do a better job. Try associating some random objects together: like “baseball in tree.”

dmx and puppy Mark Hachman / IDG

Not many problems here for either Google or Bing.

For those of you who would never search for something so detailed, that’s fine. But for me, I sometimes can’t help wondering what I’m missing.

baseball in tree Mark Hachman / IDG

You may disagree with me, but if I searched for “baseball ornament” I’d expect to see the pictures Bing found. I think Google’s results more closely match the original “baseball in tree” query.

Flight data is bogged down by ads

Bing may have recently launched comprehensive services to improve the hotel booking experience by aggregating third-party data, but the company’s basic travel search still remains underpowered. Take a generic search, “flights to Hawaii.”

flights to hawaii Mark Hachman / IDG

I’ve had to scroll down on Bing’s page to get past the superfluous ads.

You can make a basic assumption, as Bing does, that you’ll want to fly into Hawaii’s main airport, in Honolulu. Both Bing and Google establish your origin airport via your location, which is fine with me. But Bing does two things wrong here: One, it makes you click on a follow-up button to check flight information and fares; and two, it should provide a list or drop-down menu of islands or airports. Bing does allow you to select how many passengers you want to bring, however.

What Bing doesn’t quite seem to realize is that it’s competing with specialty travel search sites like kayak.com. Google’s website, Google.com/flights, seems to recognize this, and provides a wealth of data at your fingertips. On the other hand, Bing intelligently recommends certain flights as the best for a given set of criteria, as per this search for flights to New York City. 

flights to jfk best flights Mark Hachman / IDG

After asking Bing to find flights, or clicking through to Google’s flights page, you receive this result. Both search engines largely settle on the same “best flights,” though Google offers far more customization options.

Personalization’s benefits are what, exactly?

Another interesting element of the “ThinkPad” search within Bing News: The top results remain unchanged, regardless of whether I sign into Bing. As a journalist, I admit that personalized results aren’t always beneficial. If PCWorld editors are trying to assess the relative importance of a particular search term, we search anonymously. This is an anomaly, however, and it goes back to the old search conundrum: If I’m searching for “apple,” am I looking for a Red Delicious, or the computer company? If I’m allowing Bing or Google to capture my data, shouldn’t I benefit?

Interestingly, Google seems to give me the same top search results when searching for Apple whether logged in, or anonymous. But I noticed one difference: When logged into Bing, Bing surfaced several images of apples (the fruit) within its images tab. Google apparently knew (or guessed) that the Apple Inc. logo was what I was looking for. Both identified Apple Stores near me.

apple Mark Hachman / IDG

A search for “Apple” is pretty neck-and-neck, thanks in part to Bing’s strength in encyclopedic general search. 

Really, this isn’t so much of a Bing-vs.-Google issue as it is just a question of what benefit you gain for trading off your privacy. I realize that personalized data is designed to influence ads, not search results. But isn’t it time we got a bit more out of the deal? 

Bing’s redemption: answers

There is one search segment where Bing runs neck-and-neck, or even ahead of, Google. When asked a basic question (“how tall is the Eiffel Tower?” “How old was Lincoln?”), Bing acts less like a search engine and more like an encyclopedia, answering the question and then encouraging further exploration via related facts. Google does well here, too. Part of this involves using the sidebar area to the right of the main search results to provide more information. 

how tall is the eiffel tower Mark Hachman / IDG

Bing and Google show essentially the same information for a generic search query like this one.

For even an exceedingly generic search term (“Berlin”) Bing brings up things to do, facts, images, and news. Google does as well, though, and offers to plan a trip. While Bing comes off well in this comparison, I think Google goes a bit further in providing a user-friendly experience. (As well as e-commerce opportunities.)

berlin Mark Hachman / IDG

I think Google’s search (right) for “Berlin” is more comprehensive than Bing’s (left), but man, those news cards are ugly. (On both panes I’ve scrolled over to the right to include sidebar information.)

Microsoft’s management clearly believes that Bing’s road to success lies in this broad middle ground of frequently-searched terms, rather than in some of the more specific niches that I’ve highlighted. “Bing it” may never become a common verb. But if I’m turning more and more to Google, I just wonder how many other people will make Google their default search engine—for the first time in several years, I’m considering it myself.

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.
Keep up with the latest tech news, reviews and previews by subscribing to the Good Gear Guide newsletter.

Mark Hachman

PC World (US online)
Show Comments

Father’s Day Gift Guide

Brand Post

Most Popular Reviews

Latest Articles

Resources

PCW Evaluation Team

Luke Hill

MSI GT75 TITAN

I need power and lots of it. As a Front End Web developer anything less just won’t cut it which is why the MSI GT75 is an outstanding laptop for me. It’s a sleek and futuristic looking, high quality, beast that has a touch of sci-fi flare about it.

Emily Tyson

MSI GE63 Raider

If you’re looking to invest in your next work horse laptop for work or home use, you can’t go wrong with the MSI GE63.

Laura Johnston

MSI GS65 Stealth Thin

If you can afford the price tag, it is well worth the money. It out performs any other laptop I have tried for gaming, and the transportable design and incredible display also make it ideal for work.

Andrew Teoh

Brother MFC-L9570CDW Multifunction Printer

Touch screen visibility and operation was great and easy to navigate. Each menu and sub-menu was in an understandable order and category

Louise Coady

Brother MFC-L9570CDW Multifunction Printer

The printer was convenient, produced clear and vibrant images and was very easy to use

Edwina Hargreaves

WD My Cloud Home

I would recommend this device for families and small businesses who want one safe place to store all their important digital content and a way to easily share it with friends, family, business partners, or customers.

Featured Content

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?