Topfield TRF-7170 PVR

A great PVR for digital TV recording, but some of its other features could use modernising

  • Review
  • Specs
  • Images
  • User Reviews
  • Buy Now 2
Topfield TRF-7170 PVR
  • Topfield TRF-7170 PVR
  • Topfield TRF-7170 PVR
  • Expert Rating

    3.75 / 5
  • User Rating

    2.00 / 5 (of 3 Reviews)

Pros

  • Strong recording features
  • 1TB storage
  • Two USB ports

Cons

  • Menu and system features need modernising
  • Remote control could be better

Bottom Line

We really like the Topfield TRF-7170 as a recording device. It can record up to four shows through its two HD tuners and its EPG and recording features are very useful. However, its menu interface and media features could use some updating to make them more enjoyable, and its remote control could use more comfortable buttons and a better layout.

Would you buy this?

  • Buy now (Selling at 2 stores)

  • Smith Sunglasses AUDIBLE Polarized TRF/S3 231.95
  • Smith Sunglasses NOMAD Polarized TRF/S3 231.95
See all prices

The Topfield TRF-7170 is a unit that specialises in digital TV recording. It has two tuners and a 1TB hard drive, and it can record up to 4 program streams from two channels simultaneously. It's also one of the first units on the Australian market to support what Topfield calls "Intelligent Recording", which allows you to record an entire series with one simple recording action.

Comprehensive recording features

Indeed, the Topfield does excel when it comes to recording, and it's the best unit to consider if you're sole purpose for wanting a PVR is to record TV shows. The built-in EPG brings up a grid of all the programs on the free-to-air schedule and allows you to select programs for later viewing or recording simply by clicking on them. You can schedule up to four recordings during the same time period as long as they are from two channels. For example, you can record something from GEM and GO, which are on channel Nine, and something from 7Two and 7Mate, which are on Seven. While recording two or more programs, you'll only be able to watch programs from those two channels that you're recording from, or you could play back a previous recording.

Intelligent Recording is a feature supported by this Topfield out of the box and it's simply an option that appears when you're in the EPG, which allows you to flag a show for series recording. By recording one episode using Intelligent recording (the blue option on the remote), it will record that program whenever it appears on the schedule. By default, it also adds five minutes of padding to the start and finish times of the recordings, but this can be tweaked in the system menu. The padding also works on regular scheduled recordings. Manual recordings (pressing the record button while watching) last up to two hours. The unit also supports time-shifting from 30min to five hours.

Getting to recorded programs takes a couple of button presses with the supplied remote control and programs default to an alphabetical listing, rather than date. To sort recordings by date, you have to press the white button on the remote (options) and select 'Time' as the sort option. The menu is transparent by default and can be hard to see sometimes, but you can set the transparency level to zero from the Settings menu. If you stop a recording, then you will go back watching live TV rather than back to the menu for recorded programs. We found this annoying.

The EPG can be invoked by pressing the Guide button on the remote. It's a grid that shows three hours worth of programs and seven channels per screen. It's intuitive to read and the current show you are watching is highlighted in yellow. Show names are displayed for the most part, but there are some small, blank boxes for programs that are less than 30min in length. For these, you'll need to click on the 'i' (information) button on the remote to see what they are. To record programs, simply press the OK button on the remote until a red 'R' appears in the program box. You can also just tell the Topfield to switch to a certain program at its start time (withut recording it) so that you don't miss it when it's aired live.

Web interface and Divx playback

You can leave recordings on the internal 1TB hard drive, or you can copy them to a USB drive, or even try to transfer them to your computer by connecting the Topfield to your network (via the Ethernet port at the rear of the unit) and enabling its Web server. We say "try" because it's a bit of a temperamental feature that did not always work properly during our test period. Sometimes, transfers would stop and the interface would crash, requiring us to switch it off and on again. It's a problem that we also faced with the TRF-7160, although we fixed that by applying a firmware update.

We checked for a firmware update for the 7170 during our tests, but one wasn't available. Playing back files on a PC can't be done through Windows Media Player. You'll need to use a player such as KMplayer. This unit doesn't have the ability to stream video off other locations on your network, that feature is reserved for the TRF-2460 Masterpiece HD.

In addition to viewing and recording free-to-air TV, the Topfield can be used to play back Divx files from a hard drive. This feature is still primitive, and this is a criticism we had of the previous Topfield that we saw, the TRF-7160. Topfield really needs to work to make not just this feature, but the entire menu a little more user friendly. It's starting to show its age and it's definitely not as good as the menus on other PVRs we've seen, such as the Humax HDR-7500T.

Physcial features

Physically, the Topfield is a full-width unit that will take up a space as wide as 43cm in your entertainment cabinet. Its design hasn't really changed compared to previous Topfield units we've seen. It still has an annoying blue LED that's displayed when the unit is in standby mode and it still has a USB port on the front as well as USB, eSATA, 100Mbps Ethernet, digital audio (coaxial and optical), Component, Composite and analogue audio output at the back. Only one antenna input is needed, and it has a pass-through antenna connection, too, which is handy if you want to hook up any other device in your setup with a TV signal.

We're not fans of the Topfield's remote control, which has buttons that too small and spongy. Furthermore, the layout of the keys is awkward, especially the location of the playback buttons. This is another area that Topfield needs to modernise.

Conclusion

Basically, the Topfield isn't a perfect unit. Its menu system, media playback capabilities and its remote control now seem dated and could all be better. On the plus side, it has a 1TB hard drive and its recording features are the best in the business. Consider this unit if you're an avid TV watcher and recorder of programs, and you don't really care about other features such as playing Divx files. Recording is what this unit does best.

Keep up with the latest tech news, reviews and previews by subscribing to the Good Gear Guide newsletter.

Bill Stent

1

Just bought one of these 7170 units from JB HiFi. It's going back to the shop the day after. I don't know if it's a problem with the unit or we're doing something wrong. It says it's going to record a show, that the reservation is correctly set up and saved. When the end of the program passes, the recording either deletes itself (if it's a one-time recording) or reschedules for the next occurrence (if it's an intelligent recording), as you'd expect. But the saved recordings are nowhere to be found on the hard drive. It might be a dodgy HDD, but it's made some timeshifting recordings OK, which look great, so I think the HDD is OK. It might be some advanced setting that says "program fine, but don't actually record", but this one is out of the box so you'd expect any default to be to save the recording.

R Staff

2

My 6 week old 7170 from JB HIFI worked perfectly for the 1st 4 weeks, then it started missing recordings and would't allow access to previously recorded programs. Formatted the hard drive, reset it to factory defaults, it then worked for one day and came up with the same problems. It also developed an intermittent rattle. It's going back to the shop tomorrow. Firmare update was applied at initial setup.Very dissapointing.

Geoffrey

3

I am a very disappointed user. I migrated from TiVo, and have to explain the lost program's, missed endings to the family. This 7170 drive is appalling, and I should have stuck with TiVo.

Frank

4

I have bought 3 of these units because I do a lot of tv recording they have been great one of the units
Does seem to get low boom boom sound which is very annoying I will do some tests by moving it to another tv and see it still does it then send it back to have it checked

Carl

5

Have had my TRF-7170 for twelve months and have never been really satisfied with it. The EPG is often on the wrong day and/or th wrong time of day and when you try to correct the problem, it either will not provide the data or leaps ahead two days.

I do not use it very often because I also have Foxtel IQ which is so much better and simpler to use in both record and replay. But the Topfield come in handy if you want to record a free to air programme when the IQ is tied up with two Foxtel programmes.

I just turned it off to move it to another room and when I turned it back on, I had lost all the recorded programmes, all the reserved recording information and now It will not allow me to record any programmes straight from the screen, or to record any programmes of the EPG.

I have had enough. It will be consigned to the bin aand I will look for another digital recording machine.

Post new comment

Users posting comments agree to the Good Gear Guide comments policy.

Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.

Most Popular Reviews

Follow Us

Best Deals on GoodGearGuide

Shopping.com

Latest News Articles

Resources

GGG Evaluation Team

Kathy Cassidy

STYLISTIC Q702

First impression on unpacking the Q702 test unit was the solid feel and clean, minimalist styling.

Anthony Grifoni

STYLISTIC Q572

For work use, Microsoft Word and Excel programs pre-installed on the device are adequate for preparing short documents.

Steph Mundell

LIFEBOOK UH574

The Fujitsu LifeBook UH574 allowed for great mobility without being obnoxiously heavy or clunky. Its twelve hours of battery life did not disappoint.

Andrew Mitsi

STYLISTIC Q702

The screen was particularly good. It is bright and visible from most angles, however heat is an issue, particularly around the Windows button on the front, and on the back where the battery housing is located.

Simon Harriott

STYLISTIC Q702

My first impression after unboxing the Q702 is that it is a nice looking unit. Styling is somewhat minimalist but very effective. The tablet part, once detached, has a nice weight, and no buttons or switches are located in awkward or intrusive positions.

Latest Jobs

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?