Jawbone UP3 review: 3 months with Jawbone's best fitness tracker
The UP3 gleans data on your physiology and then offers insights on how to be more active, eat better, sleep better and live better.
- One of the smallest designs for a fitness tracker
- 5-day battery life with half hour recharge time
- The ability to log workouts and food
- Smart Coach makes data on your physiology easy to understand
- Calculates resting heart rate
- Splash resistant and durable body
- Nothing. Maybe the charging method could be better.
Price$ 229.00 (AUD)
I don't usually write reviews in the first person, but Jawbone's UP warrants the change in tone. Other technology devices tell the story of a company – what they’re doing and where they’re going – but the flagship fitness tracker from Jawbone tells your story. It registers how active you are in the day, what you eat throughout and logs details on your sleeping patterns.
I’ve been living with the UP3 for more than three months. I’ve taken it off only a handful of times. Yes, that means I’ve showered with it.
The old UP24 used to have batteries running through the arms of the bracelet. It was thick all the way around and was hampered by an awkward design. On one end was a removable cap that concealed a 2.5mm jack; it would’ve been easy to lose. No doubt the UP24 was held back by day's technical limitations.
The UP3 is smaller and smarter. The only bulge on its body takes place at the top, which is where the batteries, a capacitive display and a number of sensors are housed. The rest of it is wafer thin, although there are four contacts running along the band. They are not intrusive and are there to measure your resting heart rate.
A clever latch locks the bracelet in place. It presses against the skin gingerly; a requisite if it is to glean heart readings or discern one stage of sleep from another. PC World editor Elias Plastiras and I are in disagreement on this part the UP’s design. He wears watches rather loosely and dislikes having his UP2 – which has the same design – pressing against his skin.
After a week I altogether forget the UP3 is on my wrist. I take it off for brief breaks when I’m sitting down – it’s resting on the desk as I type these words. But I will put it back on for a trip as brief as a bathroom break.
The UP3 only accounts for one half of the Jawbone experience. Its capacitive display lights up a trio of icons that reveal its current mode. Alternating between them necessitates a bunch of taps – more than three – so that it doesn’t switch modes every time it takes a knock.
Viewing this data involves a nifty smartphone application. All of the data recorded is transferred to your smartphone over low energy Bluetooth. Some trackers provide an almost real-time update on your daily progress. The UP3 is not that kind of tracker. Jawbone claims it’ll update every five minutes, but in the real world, when Bluetooth is occasionally switched off, or when you walk beyond its range, this assertion wanes in credibility. Often the UP3 will be prompted to update whenever its companion application is opened.
Waiting for the application to refresh can be maddening – there are days PCWorld’s editor muses on this gripe. I see value in this method for two reasons.
It means I get to see the data on my schedule. Wearables are incredibly intimate pieces of technology. At every hour of every day, I don’t want to be notified on an immaterial statistic. The best wearables will disappear into the background, meeting our needs by blending into our lifestyle, and then when we’re ready, they will tell us what we’ve done and what needs doing.
The second reason pertains to battery life. Jawbone claims the UP3 will last a week between charges. Over three months, the battery capacity of my UP has shed a day or two. A magnetised charger replenishes the battery in half an hour, which is less time than it takes to get ready for work.
The trick up Jawbone’s sleeve is a personal trainer called Smart Coach. It assesses the data gleaned by the tracker and then makes the numbers digestible by giving them context. When I glance at my progress, Smart Coach shows my step count and sleeping patterns as a percentage. “101 per cent”, it’ll read, and I’ll know I’ve surpassed my daily goal.
It records steps in the same way a personal trainer counts sit ups; if it’s a half step, then it doesn’t count. Wear both a Fitbit and a Jawbone and the Fitbit’s step count will be fractionally higher. All pedometers vary in accuracy. I consider Jawbone’s to be accurate, but more importantly, it is consistent. In the pursuit of fitness, it is better to undercount than overcount.
Pass a hundred per cent and the UP3 will offer its congratulations by vibrating and flashing its lights. The fitness tracker is clever enough to identify that you have been active, but it lacks the intuition to identify the activity type. Once you enter the workout type, it will add its data on the workout’s intensity. Exceed the daily record in successive days and you’ll be on a streak. Feel-good platitudes are offered in the spirit of positive reinforcement. These include:
- “You’ve reached 1 million steps with UP! No matter how you slice it - 805km, 19 marathons, the distance from San Francisco to Mexico - you are looking good.”
- “You started the day off a little behind pace, but you really turned it around in the afternoon... Enjoy your turnaround story.”
- “Stanford University found that creativity improves while a person is walking, as well as shortly after. That makes today an ideal time for your passion project.”
Miss a target and Smart Coach will be there with a constructive consolation, such as the following:
- “You are close to maintaining your 7-day, 6,046 step average! Another 496 steps, or a 5 minute walk will take you there.”
- “You’ve taken a total of 44,526 steps since last Monday. Think of all the energy you’ve generated with those moves, then make today worth remembering.”
- “Your 2 week digest: This week’s 6,046 step 7-day average is lower than the previous week’s 6,717 average. Smart Coach does have some good news. Your 7h 10m 7-day sleep average is higher than the previous week’s 6h 16m average. Use the energy from those extra zzzs while sleeping. Goal victories in the last 14 days: Move - 2 Sleep - 1”
The same diligent encouragement is applied to its tracking of food and changes in your sleeping patterns.
Meals have to be entered manually, but the app streamlines the process by accessing a vast database. Your meal can be logged one ingredient at a time, or by selecting an existing entry. Other methods include scanning barcodes by using the smartphone’s camera or simply taking a photo of the meal. Eating habits are qualified into colour coded categories: Red for ‘not so good’, yellow for ‘not bad’ and green for ‘well done’.
Smart Coach is just as involved in your dietary progress as it is in your daily activity. It will offer insights on how you can specifically, and progressively, improve your nutritional habits. I’ve always eaten well, but the day’s deadlines cause me to rehydrate with coffee, and not water, even though my throat will be as dry as a camel’s. The oversight has caused me discomfort.
“You took 223 steps below your 7-day average yesterday,” Smart Coach will note, “but your resting heart rate was high this morning. Dehydration may be the cause. When you’re extra active, stay extra hydrated.”
Then it will challenge me. "It’s on! You will drink 8 glasses of water today, so grab your goblet. Your mind will thank you tomorrow.”
The feedback it provides you with will be tailored to your health and lifestyle.
Having covered 16 hours of the day with exercise and food intake, the UP3 will then make detailed assessments on sleeping patterns. Jawbone’s U24 required a sleep mode be prompted before hitting the pillow, and failing to do so would result in a generic summary of your sleep. The UP3 will still return detailed insights on your sleep even if you forget to enable the mode.
It will break sleep down into three different categories: REM, light and deep sleep. Qualifying the kind of sleep would be trivial if the tracker failed to communicate why each type is important.
- “Last night’s sleep included 2h 20m of REM sleep. REM is the sleep stage most associated with dreaming, If you want to learn more about the science behind different types of dreams, tap the link.”
- “Now that you’re smiling, let’s make this new bedtime a habit. Go to bed by 10.28pm again tonight to establish your new sleep routine.”
Being handed the information is one thing. Knowing what to do with it is another. Jawbone is aware that our sleeping habits inform our productivity in the coming days.
New to the UP3 is its ability to read a heart rate. A multitude of other devices capture heart rate readings in real time, but this information is only useful in particular situations. For instance, I would use the metric when running on a treadmill to measure the intensity of the workout, but during the other 23 hours in the day...
Jawbone uses the heart rate reading for an overview of your health. Readings take place once a day, in the moments when light sleep turns to consciousness, because that timeframe is free from factors that will dilute a heart reading. It is before you have coffee, grow irritated or take on straining activity.
Smart Coach reveals the average person’s resting heart rate is from 60 to 100 beats per minute, and that athletes have been recorded with a resting heart rate as low as 40 beats per minute.
A resting heart rate takes many factors into consideration – your sleep, your diet and your fitness level – and boils it all down into one number. The application will recognise trends in an increased heart rate and make suggestions on how it can be improved.
Wearables are incredibly personal devices. The one you buy requires the same consideration that goes into getting a body piercing or a tattoo. Nor will buying a fitness tracker make you fitter – that endeavour continues to require discipline and hard work. But finding the right fitness tracker will make it easier.
Jawbone’s UP will empower you with information on your physiology, on your heart beat and your sleeping patterns, guide your dieting and remind you to stay hydrated. It’ll give you that power. What is done with it is up to you.
For me, the change is as small as drinking eight glasses of water each day.
Join the Good Gear Guide newsletter!
Most Popular Reviews
- 1 Fetch TV Mighty review: Better than Foxtel
- 2 Fetch TV Mini review: Make your TV a smart TV
- 3 Parrot Mambo Drone review
- 4 Evapolar USB air conditioner review
- 5 Hisense Series 7 ULED 4K UHD TV review
Latest News Articles
- Report: Google to sell its own Android Wear watch in early 2017
- The runner-focused Apple Watch Nike+ launches on October 28
- Valve dangles new HTC Vive VR controller prototypes at Steam Dev Days
- Hands-on: Sony N is a Google Glass for your neck, with an assistant named Nigel
- Oculus teases a standalone Rift headset that blends the best of PC and mobile VR
GGG Evaluation Team
First impression on unpacking the Q702 test unit was the solid feel and clean, minimalist styling.
For work use, Microsoft Word and Excel programs pre-installed on the device are adequate for preparing short documents.
The Fujitsu LifeBook UH574 allowed for great mobility without being obnoxiously heavy or clunky. Its twelve hours of battery life did not disappoint.
The screen was particularly good. It is bright and visible from most angles, however heat is an issue, particularly around the Windows button on the front, and on the back where the battery housing is located.
My first impression after unboxing the Q702 is that it is a nice looking unit. Styling is somewhat minimalist but very effective. The tablet part, once detached, has a nice weight, and no buttons or switches are located in awkward or intrusive positions.
- Google Pixel XL full, in-depth smartphone review: The new best Android phone
- TV buying guide: What to look for when buying a TV in 2016
- Best iPhone 7 and iPhone 7 Plus plans: Optus vs Telstra vs Vodafone vs Virgin
- Which flagship TV is best? Sony 4K HDR Bravia 2016 versus LG 4K HDR OLED 2016
- 10 Blu-ray movies / Best looking Blu-ray movies
- CCProject Manager - Payroll SystemsSA
- FTTest ManagerNSW
- CCSenior Project Manager (Marketing Automation)NSW
- CCNetwork AdministratorVIC
- CCSenior Full Stack Java DeveloperNSW
- CCContract Analyst Programmer (CISCO/IT Security) 161028/AP/142Asia
- CCContract Analyst Programmer (HTML/JAVA/J2EE) 161025/AP/862Asia
- CCData Centre EngineerNSW
- CCSAS DI DeveloperNSW
- FTProject ManagerSA
- CCBusiness Process Specialist/AnalystNSW
- CCBusiness AnalystNSW
- CCSenior Business Analyst, Margin ProjectsNSW
- FTBiomedical Project ManagerSA
- CCApplications Support Technical OfficerACT
- CCCisco Wi-Fi Network Engineer - SurveyorNSW
- CCTest Engineer - .NETNSW
- FTSOE ArchitectNSW
- CCAgile Business AnalystVIC
- CCContract Analyst Programmer (Web Programming) 161013/AP/185Asia
- CCContract IT Assistant (Office Automation) 161031/ITA/541Asia
- CCContract Senior Systems Analyst (Oracle/SSADM) 161027/SSA/634Asia
- CCContract Senior Systems Analyst (JAVA/Oracle) 161012/SSA/623Asia
- CCMobile Developers (IOS and Android)QLD
- CCJava Developers - Federal Government experienceNSW