HP Envy 17 notebook

HP's Envy 17 is a desktop replacement with plenty of speed under the hood, uses fourth-gen Core i7

  • Review
  • Specs
  • Images
  • User Reviews (3)
  • Buy Now 5
  • Broadband Plans
HP Envy 17 notebook
  • HP Envy 17 notebook
  • HP Envy 17 notebook
  • HP Envy 17 notebook
  • Expert Rating

    3.00 / 5
  • User Rating

    4.00 / 5 (of 3 Reviews)

Pros

  • Fast CPU
  • Lots of RAM
  • Plenty of internal storage

Cons

  • Bouncy keyboard
  • Only single-band Wi-Fi
  • No touchscreen

Bottom Line

HP's Envy 17 is a big notebook that's suitable as a desktop replacement computer. It has a fourth-generation Intel Core i7 CPU, discrete NVIDIA graphics, and it can be used for almost any mainstream computing task. For the asking price, though, it could use better Wi-Fi, a touchscreen and some refinement in its build quality.

Would you buy this?

  • Buy now (Selling at 5 stores)

  • ENVY 4500 e-All-in-One 74.25
  • ENVY17TS-J110TX I7-4702MQ,17.3 FHD, TOUCH + LEA... 2248.40
  • ENVY15-J005TU I7-4700MQ,15.6 HD,4GB,750GB,W8,SI... 898.70
See all prices

Our first glimpse of a fourth-generation Intel Core i7-equipped notebook comes in the form of HP's very large Envy 17. It's designed to be a stay-at-home computer, and it's powerful enough to replace a desktop for most tasks. You can perform typical productivity tasks quickly thanks to its strong configuration, and it has the ability to also run many games quite well.

A big unit

The 17.3in size might not have mass appeal, but it's ideal for those of you who want a large machine that can be used for long stretches of productivity or entertainment. Its screen is huge and it comes fitted with a Full HD panel; its keyboard includes a number pad and its palm rest is spacious; it has enough built-in features to please those of you who don't have any niche or legacy needs.

It can be difficult to construct large laptops without making them overly bulky or very heavy, but HP has done a decent job with the Envy 17, making it look clean and feel sturdy. It's still heavy, though; at 3kg, it doesn't lend itself to lap usage and you won't want to take it on the road too often either (if at all). You can definitely use it anywhere around your home that's not near an outlet, but that's as mobile as it gets with this model. In our battery rundown test, in which we disable power management, enable Wi-Fi, maximise screen brightness and loop an Xvid-encoded video, it lasted 2hr 53min. This time is similar to what a third-generation Core i7-based 17.3in laptop would get.

We did find one problem with the build quality; when we attempted to eject the optical drive, it wouldn't budge. The tray kept getting caught on the top part of the chassis. In order for it to open, we had to push down on the chassis just above the optical drive. We're hoping it's just a quirk of our test model, otherwise, if you use this notebook for a lot of CD or DVD ripping, you might get very annoyed with it. That area of the laptop around the optical drive felt flimsy.

Configuration and performance

Along the edges, you get four USB 3.0 ports, HDMI, Gigabit Ethernet, an SD card slot, and a Blu-ray writer. On the inside you get a configuration that's anchored by a fourth-generation Intel Core i7-4700MQ CPU, which is a mobile CPU with four cores and Hyper-Threading that runs at 2.4GHz (its Turbo Boost allows it to hit 3.4GHz). It's joined by 16GB of DDR3 SDRAM, an NVIDIA GeForce GT 740M graphics adapter (it has 2GB of its own RAM) and there are two 1TB, 5400rpm hard drives installed (one for the system, one for data, and some space is also set aside for the recovery partition).

On the left side, you get the air vent, HDMI, Gigabit Ethernet, two USB 3.0 ports and an SD card slot.
On the left side, you get the air vent, HDMI, Gigabit Ethernet, two USB 3.0 ports and an SD card slot.

The right side has the headset port, two USB 2.0 ports and the hard-to-open Blu-ray writer.
The right side has the headset port, two USB 2.0 ports and the hard-to-open Blu-ray writer.

It's a configuration that supplies very good speed for typical office suites, Web browsing, photo editing, and even video editing. You can even use it to play games thanks to the discrete NVIDIA graphics adapter, though you probably won't be able to run many of them at the native 1920x1080-pixel resolution of the screen. In 3DMark06, the GeForce graphics put up a respectable score of 10382, while in the latest 3DMark, a score of 53208 was recorded in the entry-level Ice Storm test, 7065 in the mid-range Cloud Gate test, and 1031 in the high-end Fire Strike test.

In our Blender 3D test, the Envy 17 recorded a time of only 19sec. This is the same time that we've seen from gaming laptops that use a third-generation 2.4GHz CPU (the Core i7-3630QM), such as the MSI GT70 Dragon Edition. Likewise, our iTunes MP3 encoding test recorded a time of 42sec, which is one second slower than what the third-gen MSI laptop achieved. Where the fourth-gen CPU sped things up was in the in the Handbrake test, in which the HP took 8min 52sec to convert a DVD file to an MP4. This is 1min 2sec faster than the MSI laptop.

The storage performance wasn't too bad considering that the Envy 17 doesn't have any solid state drive (SSD) speed enhancements; you only get mechanical hard drives, and there are two of them. They are both 1TB, 5400rpm hard drives, but you can replace them with SSDs if you want extra speed in the future (the access panel comes off easily). In CrystalDiskMark, the system drive recorded a rate of 114 megabytes per second (MBps) for both reading and writing. When copying data from a USB 3.0 hard drive such as the Toshiba Canvio, the average transfer rate was 50.72MBps.

Other features

Other features of the HP Envy 17 include Intel Centrino Wireless-N 2230 Wi-Fi (it's single-band only, which is a disappointment at this price point), Bluetooth and there is also a fingerprint reader. The fingerprint reader can be used with the pre-installed SimplePass utility to log you in to Windows and Web sites (via your default browser) with the swipe of a finger. It worked fine with Firefox and Internet Explorer; when we visited a site that we had to log in to, a message from SimplePass appeared and asked us if we would like to save that information. The neat thing is, you can swipe your finger to bring up a list of all the sites for which you've got credentials stored and go straight to them from there, without having to even launch your browser manually.

HP has the Beats audio logo embossed on the chassis of this notebook, which is meant to mean that good sound quality is one of its key selling points. In reality, the Envy 17 is a disappointment in this area. For starters, it doesn't have separate output and input ports (only one combination headset port), and its speakers, even though there are six of them installed (it claims to have two sub-woofers), don't produce the type of output that we thought would make this notebook stand out. The sound is not loud enough to fill a relatively small room, and it struggles to reproduce subtle sounds such as quiet bass lines. Basically, and as with most notebooks, you'll still have to plug in headphones or speakers for high-quality listening.

We like the large screen though, which has a Full HD resolution and isn't glossy. It has decent brightness and contrast for viewing photos and working with productivity applications, but it can look a little dull when it comes to displaying videos — especially dark ones. The lack of touchscreen input on this notebook actually disappointed us. We've seen so many touchscreen notebooks over the last few months, to the point that we're now quite used to tapping or swiping the screen during the regular course of our work. The hinges seem strong enough to be able to handle any back and forth movement resulting from tapping the screen, and the $1999 price tag, we think, is enough to warrant the feature's inclusion. A touchscreen would make it a little heavier though, which we don't think is a problem because it's a heavy unit to start with, and it will also cause some reflections, but not enough to negate the benefit that the touch interface would bring to Windows 8's Start screen in particular.

The backlit keyboard is good for the most part, but it bounces a little and its arrow keys, in particular, are way too cramped.
The backlit keyboard is good for the most part, but it bounces a little and its arrow keys, in particular, are way too cramped.

The keyboard is backlit and the keys are soft to hit. Despite being such a large laptop, the keyboard feels a little cramped. The arrow keys are an example of this as they are squished in to a tiny area, and there also isn't much of a gap between the number pad and the main keyboard. That said, we didn't have a bad time typing on this laptop, and it actually felt quite decent, especially because it has such a generous palm rest. Our only problem with it is that it's a very bouncy keyboard. It appears as though there aren't enough mounting points for the keyboard tray on the chassis.

Conclusion

There's not much else to the HP Envy 17. It's a notebook that's best suited to those of you who need a desktop replacement with fast processing and an ability to play some games. It can easily be hooked up to an external big screen, and it has enough USB ports to cater to wired input peripherals and external storage at the same time. It's also one of the few consumer notebooks on the Australian market to have a fingerprint reader. On the downside, it's missing dual-band Wi-Fi, the speakers aren't great, the optical drive didn't open properly during our tests, the keyboard is bouncy and a little cramped in some areas, and it lacks a touchscreen.

Related Windows 8 laptop reviews:

Panasonic Toughbook CF-AX2 convertible Ultrabook
Acer Aspire R7 convertible notebook
Sony VAIO Pro 13 Ultrabook
Sony VAIO S Series notebook
Toshiba KIRA Ultrabook
Gigabyte U2442F Extreme Ultrabook
Toshiba Satellite P870 notebook
Medion Akoya E6232 (MD 99222) notebook
Dell Inspiron 17R notebook
Acer Aspire V5 touchscreen laptop
Toshiba Satellite P840 touchscreen notebook
MSI GT70 Dragon Edition gaming notebook
ASUS VivoBook S400C touchscreen Ultrabook
Samsung Ativ Smart PC 500T hybrid tablet
Venom Blackbook Windows 8 gaming notebook
Sony VAIO Duo 11 Windows 8 tablet
ASUS VivoTab 810 Windows 8 tablet
Lenovo ThinkPad Twist (3347-3EM)
Samsung Ativ Smart PC Pro 700T (XE700T1C-A02AU)
HP Envy X2 hybrid PC
HP Envy Touchsmart 4 Ultrabook
Toshiba Satellite L850 Windows 8 laptop
ASUS Taichi 21 Windows 8 hybrid Ultrabook
Medion Akoya S4216 (MD 99081) Windows 8 Ultrabook
Toshiba Satellite U920T hybrid Ultrabook
Dell XPS 12 convertible Ultrabook
ASUS Vivo Book F202 touchscreen notebook
Acer Aspire S7 touchscreen Ultrabook

Alternative Windows tablet product reviews

Lenovo ThinkPad Helix convertible Ultrabook
Microsoft Surface Pro tablet
ASUS Vivo Tab RT Windows Tablet
Microsoft Surface RT

Keep up with the latest tech news, reviews and previews by subscribing to the Good Gear Guide newsletter.

Read more on these topics: notebooks, HP, fourth generation core

Al

1

The problem with opening the DVD tray is easily fixed-turn the power on. I ha the same problem at first then stumbled upon the solution. It must be a safety to help prevent the tray from opening during transport.

Post new comment

Users posting comments agree to the Good Gear Guide comments policy.

Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.

Brocky

4.5

1

Pros
I have only had it a week. I would love to have had the SSID drive but apart from that so far I'm happy
Cons
I notice no one else has complained about the DVD drive. Very flimsy id gets caught on the frame of the computer base ejects on its own rattles like it's unbalanced and will not load or eject sometimes.
• • •

As I said only had it a week I do like it i have upgraded it's software and windows 8.1, one annoying thing i find in windows is your on a page or program and it closes you have to go over to the left of screen and open the page again. Battery has short life span. will update in a few weeks. I do like the fingerprint security so no one can open your computer unless the happen to cut off the right one.....LOL Hoping that I can play some games on it as I am partially disabled I have desktop playstation and Ipad.

Rich

2.5

2

Pros
startup speed, back-lit keyboard
Cons
full SSD main drive not available, very poor WIFI card (reception), occasional video glitches with HDMI output.
• • •

When ordering this laptop, I was disappointed that HP didn't offer a SSD as a main drive, had to settle for their "hybrid" 1 TB drive (small SSD cache and a 5500 rpm mechanical drive). Odd combination (why not use a faster 7200 rpm drive). Salesman said the hybrid drive performs like a SSD.

When I got the unit, I was initially impressed. I liked the style. Nice size screen (17" as opposed to my older 15" laptop) text was easy to read, graphics looked good. Startup speed was good. I like the back-lit keyboard, especially useful in dark rooms. Built in sound was good as well (Beats system).

Then started the disappointments. I checked the Windows experience rating & saw the lowest performing component was the drive. This is after I told the salesman I wanted an SSD, This "hydrid" drive unit obviously DOESN'T perform like a SSD drive.

Then when hooked up the laptop to a large flat screen TV via HDMI the video occasionally flickered (a ghostlike image of the taskbar would appear in the middle of the screen for an instant every few seconds). My previous laptop never did that using the same HDMI cable & input on the TV. It would go away after robooting, then come back randomly.

The final straw that made me decide to return the unit was WIFI reception. This laptop could not connect to my WIFI unless it was in the same or next room of the router. When I'm upstairs or in the basement, I am able to connect with my smartphone, iPad, and older Dell laptop without any problems. In some cases, it would not even see the SSID even tough I could connect with my other devices. The WIFI card this laptop comes with seems to be a cheap/low-end version. I tried updating the driver & resetting the wireless router & still could not get it to connect in certain areas that the other devices could.

I contacted the salesman and asked if they made a unit with a better WIFI card & faster hard drive. He said the unit I got was their best.

robert

5.0

3

Pros
cpu speed, keyboard
Cons
screen
• • •

I bought it for 755 euro and put ssd, all i can say it is an amazing fast, reliable machine. I have replaced this one with 6 months old Asus n56vz i7 ssd, my java server was starting for 30-40 seconds now it starts in 14s stable (i just swapped ssd to envy and updated drivers so system is exactly the same). and the whole experience feels much smoother and faster, though all reviews says it should be only 10% faster, in real life - its almost twice.
Keyboard is superb, games running fluent on high settings.
17" screen i got is crap and glare, but you can customize it before buy. The only thing is this machine does not like windows 7 for gaming. Games are stuttering on w7 but windows 8 - no problem. I play 1900x1200 24" screen, high settings ang got 28-40 fps depending on game, with smaller resolutions no less than 50fps. Most people complain about this laptop because it comes with 2x1TB 5200rpm hilariously slow hdd's but replacing one with ssd this machine becomes alive and performing at the bottleneck that core 4700QM can provide.

Latest News Articles

Most Popular Articles

Follow Us

GGG Evaluation Team

Kathy Cassidy

STYLISTIC Q702

First impression on unpacking the Q702 test unit was the solid feel and clean, minimalist styling.

Anthony Grifoni

STYLISTIC Q572

For work use, Microsoft Word and Excel programs pre-installed on the device are adequate for preparing short documents.

Steph Mundell

LIFEBOOK UH574

The Fujitsu LifeBook UH574 allowed for great mobility without being obnoxiously heavy or clunky. Its twelve hours of battery life did not disappoint.

Andrew Mitsi

STYLISTIC Q702

The screen was particularly good. It is bright and visible from most angles, however heat is an issue, particularly around the Windows button on the front, and on the back where the battery housing is located.

Simon Harriott

STYLISTIC Q702

My first impression after unboxing the Q702 is that it is a nice looking unit. Styling is somewhat minimalist but very effective. The tablet part, once detached, has a nice weight, and no buttons or switches are located in awkward or intrusive positions.

Resources

Best Deals on GoodGearGuide

Compare broadband and save

Powered by

Need Help? Call 1300 123 935

Latest Jobs

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?