First impression on unpacking the Q702 test unit was the solid feel and clean, minimalist styling.
Samsung Series 9 notebook vs Apple MacBook Air
- — 05 May, 2011 14:05
The comparisons between Samsung's new Series 9 notebook and Apple's Macbook Air are apt. They both have almost identical dimensions and weight and a similar feature-set. But if you're in the market for a new ultraportable and you don't have an allegiance to Apple or Microsoft, then which should you choose? Ultimately, it might come down to price, but it's also important to know what type of features and technology you're getting.
In this versus article we've pitted the brand new Samsung Series 9 notebook against the high-specification version of Apple's MacBook Air (which was released in late 2010). Both the Samsung and the Apple look sexy (the Samsung is the better looking of the two in our opinion); both have full-sized keyboards and large touchpads (or trackpads if you're an Apple user), making them very comfortable to use despite their small size.
They both use different technology under the hood though, and there are a few features that set them apart. Let's take a look:
|Feature||Samsung Series 9||MacBook Air||Verdict?|
|Warranty||1 year international||1 year international AppleCare||MacBook Air|
|Operating system (OS)||Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit||OS X||Tie|
|Display technology||LED-backlit matte panel||LED-backlit glossy panel||Series 9|
|Display resolution||1366x768 pixels||1440x900 pixels||MacBook Air|
|CPU||Intel Core i5-2537||Intel Core 2 Duo SL9600||Series 9|
|RAM||4GB DDR3||4GB DDR3||Tie|
|Storage||128GB SSD||256GB SSD||MacBook Air|
|Graphics||Intel HD graphics||NVIDIA GeForce 320M||MacBook Air|
|I/O ports||2x USB (USB 2.0 and USB 3.0), Micro-HDMI, Gigabit Ethernet (via dongle), headphone/microphone, internal mic||2x USB 2.0, Mini DisplayPort, headphone, internal mic||Series 9|
|Bluetooth||3.0||2.1 EDR||Series 9|
|Memory slot||microSD||SD||MacBook Air|
|Battery||Sealed 5900mAh||Sealed 50Wh||Tie|
|Keyboard backlight||Yes, adjustable brightness||No||Series 9|
|Ambient light sensor||Yes||No||Series|
Overall, the MacBook Air, despite being older, is still a good proposition, but the Samsung is more technologically advanced. It has an ultra-low voltage Sandy Bridge CPU as opposed to an older Core 2 Duo. It's a lot more powerful than the Core 2 Duo (the Core i5 can process four software threads simultaneously as opposed to only two for the Core 2 Duo), but it has the same TDP (thermal design point) of 17W.
We like the fact that the Samsung has a backlit keyboard and matte screen. The backlit keyboard also has various levels of brightness adjustment, which is handy. The matte screen means you won't get any nasty reflections when using the notebook in a well-lit environment. However, the MacBook has a higher screen resolution of 1440x900, which is better for Web browsing and viewing high-definition photos.
As for connectivity, the Samsung has USB 3.0 while the Apple is only USB 2.0. The MacBook Air might get Thunderbolt in the notebook's next refresh though.
Both notebooks are solidly built and have smooth hinges. The Samsung's design is a little more sleek as it has hidden ports that can be exposed only when you need them. The Samsung's microSD card slot is a disadvantage compared to the regular SD card slot of the MacBook Air, especially for photographers who want to view their photos straight away, as it means a USB adapter will have to be used.
We can't wait to see what Apple brings to the table with the next MacBook Air, but at the moment, its Core 2 Duo-equipped model is still one of the best ultraportables on the market.
However, the Samsung Series 9 is the winner here. It feels absolutely great to use and has a Sandy Bridge CPU that offers much better performance than the Core 2 Duo. The extra money for the Samsung is justified when you consider the CPU.
What do you think? Let us know in the comments below.
Become a fan of PC World Australia on Facebook
Follow PC World Australia on Twitter: @PCWorldAu
Stay up to date with the latest news, reviews and features. Sign up to PC World’s newsletters