Motorola Xoom vs. Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v vs Acer Iconia A500: Android tablet showdown

Are you in the market for an Android tablet? Which is the better pick out of Motorola's Xoom, Samsung's Galaxy Tab 10.1 or Acer's Iconia A500?

Android 3.0 'Honeycomb' is Google's tablet operating system

Android 3.0 'Honeycomb' is Google's tablet operating system

Design

The Motorola Xoom features an attractive, industrial-looking black metal finish on the back and sides, and a front that taken up almost entirely by the 10.1in touchscreen. At 730g, the Xoom is a rather heavy and large device, which may be a deal-breaker for frequent commuters. It also has an oddly mounted power button on the rear.

Acer's Iconia A500 comes in at an identical weight to the Xoom, and although we liked its brushed aluminium back, curved bottom and top edges, and flat sides, the Iconia A500 is also a little on the chunky side — it is thicker, wider and longer than the Xoom. On the upside, the Acer Iconia A500 feels sturdy and well built.

The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v is a different breed altogether. It is made from sturdy feeling plastic and has a carbon-like finish on the rear. This adds a touch of style, and makes the tablet easy to grip. The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v feels well constructed despite its plastic body, and manages to remain lightweight at 599g. However, it lacks the premium feel of both the Xoom and the Iconia A500, and its rear casing creaks when pressed near the charging port, suggesting its quality can't quite match the metal design of its competitors.

Display

The Motorola Xoom, Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v and Acer Iconia A500 share identical software, and they also have very similar, capacitive touchscreen displays. All three tablets have a screen that is 10.1in in size, with a resolution of 1280x800.

The display on each of these devices produces vibrant colour and crisp text, but their glossy surface makes them tough to see in direct sunlight, and viewing angles on all three devices are a sour point. Importantly, all three tablets are responsive to touch and this results in a pleasant user experience.

The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v is made from sturdy feeling plastic and has a carbon-like finish on the rear. It manages to remain lightweight at 599g.

Internals

The Motorola Xoom, Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v and Acer Iconia A500 have similar internals. Both the Xoom and the Iconia A500 are powered by a 1GHz dual-core Nvidia Tegra 2 processor, while the Galaxy Tab 10.1v runs Samsung's own 1GHz dual-core chip. All three tablets have a hefty 1GB of RAM and at least 16GB of internal memory. The Motorola Xoom will be offered by Telstra in a 32GB variant, while the Acer Iconia A500 comes in 16GB and 32GB models.

The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v only has 16GB of internal storage, and surprisingly lacks a microSD card slot for extra storage. If you're looking for a tablet to store a hefty amount of digital media on, then this is a critical factor to consider — both the Xoom and the Iconia A500 come with a microSD card slot for memory expansion.

Cameras

If you're after a tablet with an excellent camera, the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v is the clear leader in this department. It has a rear 8-megapixel rear camera that doubles as a 1080p HD video recorder, and a 2-megapixel front camera for video calls — both take significantly better quality photos and video than the iPad 2.

The Motorola Xoom and the Acer Iconia A500 both have a 5-megapixel rear camera for photographs and video, and a 2-megapixel front camera for video calls. However, the Xoom can record 720p HD video, whereas the Acer Iconia A500 only records standard definition footage. We don't think many tablet owners will purchase one of these devices based solely on its video recording quality, but this is a feature worth considering regardless.

Other features

Acer's Iconia A500 is the only tablet out of the three to include a full USB port for transferring and storing files. This means you can plug in a USB thumb drive to quickly access your files. The Iconia A500 doesn't come preloaded with a file manager but a free download of one from the Android Market makes it easy to access files on the USB port. Even more convenient is the fact that you can plug in a USB keyboard into the Iconia A500 and use it for text input.

The Motorola Xoom has a 5-megapixel rear camera for photographs and video, and a 2-megapixel front camera for video calls. The Xoom can also record 720p HD video.

Along with a USB port, the Iconia A500 has an HDMI out port, so it can be plugged directly into a high-definition television. The Motorola Xoom also has a HDMI-out port, but doesn't have a full sized USB port. The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v is the clear loser in the extra features department — in addition to lacking a memory card slot, it lacks both HDMI-out and USB ports.

Both the Motorola Xoom and the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v tablets offer 3G connectivity, exclusively through Telstra and Vodafone respectively. It is not yet known if the Xoom sold by Telstra will be network locked (meaning you can't use another providers SIM card in it), but the Galaxy Tab 10.1v is unlocked, and can be used with a SIM card from any carrier. Surprisingly, this includes Telstra's Next G network as the Galaxy Tab 10.1v supports the 850MHz network band.

The Acer Iconia A500 is a Wi-Fi only device, but it will also be released in Wi-Fi + 3G variants at a later, unannounced date.

Battery life

Battery life is similar amongst all three tablets — Motorola and Acer promise 10 hours of video playback, while Samsung quotes seven hours. In our testing, the Galaxy Tab 10.1v often lasted over two days with moderate use, a fair result for a tablet and a significantly better figure than pre-Honeycomb Android tablets. The Acer Iconia A500 also achieved around the same.

We haven't yet had a chance to test the Motorola Xoom, but we expect it to offer similar battery life to both the Galaxy Tab 10.1v and the Iconia A500.

Pricing and availability

The Motorola Xoom will be available in May exclusively through Telstra. Pricing and availability has yet to be announced.

The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1v is exclusive to Vodafone and will be available for a limited time only, both online and in select Vodafone stores, from 4 May. The device cost $729 as an outright purchase which includes 6GB data with a three month expiry, or a $259 upfront payment, plus $39 per month over 12 months. The latter includes 1.5GB of data per month.

The Acer Iconia A500 is available now starting at $579 for the entry-level 16GB Wi-Fi model, and $678 for the 32GB Wi-Fi model, and is sold through major Australian retail outlets including Harvey Norman. Wi-Fi + 3G variants will be offered at a later date but pricing for these models has yet to be confirmed.

Further reading: The secret history of Android.

Become a fan of GoodGearGuide on Facebook

Follow GoodGearGuide on Twitter: @GoodGearGuide

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. Sign up to GoodGearGuide’s Gear Daily newsletters

Tags Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1Acer IconiaVodafoneAndroid 3.0 Honeycombtabletsmotorola xoomAndroid tabletsTelstra

Keep up with the latest tech news, reviews and previews by subscribing to the Good Gear Guide newsletter.
Ross Catanzariti

Ross Catanzariti

Good Gear Guide

15 Comments

Topryder

1

It seems like not enough work was done on honeycomb as they must have been in a big rush to release it!
There are very few apps fitted to the tab & they can't be resized to fit the large screen. Also when browzing through the apps of which there may be several hundred if you select one to read more about it & then return you are sent right back to number 1 so you have to rescroll right through the lot to get back to where you were! This is very irritating & time wasting! Flash player 2 doesn't install! This software strikes me as being without any polish or finesse. It is very rough & not a pleasure to use!

Top XCars

2

Android Honeycomb is the perfect OS for tablets. It is so cool to use it. It has so many features. It may be a little not user-friendly. Acer Iconia A500 is the best.

Henry

3

Top Ryder, you couldn't be more wrong. There are already hundreds of apps tailored specifically for honeycomb. And less than 10% of the ones I have on my phone fail to work on my tablet. I also have an ipad and an iPod.... the discrepancy was far larger going from iPod to ipad.

And while I still enjoy my ipad, mostly due to iTunes, I have to say that the Xoom actually has a much nicer tablet interface. The web browsing, notifications, and email are hands down better on the Xoom than my ipad! And even better, with 3.1 all of my music from iTunes was automatically sync'd to my Xoom without me ever having to connect it to the computer! I can't even do that on my ipad or iPod yet!

Google has been far more innovative in the tablet arena my friend.

idiotphone4lover

4

Acer Iconia A500, just $567 at Officeworks no more to pay.

Troyau

5

Actually the Iconia is $527 at Officeworks. http://www.officeworks.com.au/retail/products/Technology/Computers-and-Notebooks/Tablets/ACITA50016

Ron

6

Awesome article. I'm considering buying a tablet and this comparison was what I needed to make my decision. The acer is amazing bang for buck and people have been buying it for as low as $400 which is an absolute steal. No big deal about wifi only, I'll just tether my legend to it.

People should also realise that apps can't just be made overnight. The ipad had the same dilemma and now there is a ton of apps available. All in time.

Can't wait to buy mine

Larry

7

Motorola Xoom in Australia does not have the SD card yet, in the present model, telstra said next model in a month or so

Mel

8

You can buy the wi-fi Xoom (just make ur iPhone a hotspot) from B&H in the US for $500US - which is about $500AU!!!

Also, now that Honeycomb 3.2 is out the SD on the Xoom is up and running my friends.

Richi

9

Hey friends....you all are up ahead of me....i just want to ask something bout Tablet...Acer or samsung galaxy ??? dis question is making me crazy since month....Is it worth to buy Acer inconia A500..??? as i hav iPhone so i can use hotspot ...clarity and process wise is it worth to buy..??? waiting for reply

baq

10

i used wifi only tablet with prepaid pocket wifi. i just need a bluetooth keyboard to leave netbook at home

jennifer wade

11

Acer has done the perfect job, i am surprised to see their work quality. They way they have merged their skills with honeycomb. All around the globe Acer is going to dominate the platform of android devices. This year competition is going bigger & bigger as few big names like OZiTechnology.com and Amazon.com are also fully prepared to contribute big in android world.

Deen

12

Well, it forgot to mention barometer in Xoom.

Oddvar

13

I have the samsung galaxy tab 10.1v, and I am thrilled by what it can do. But the information you have given above is wrong. My galaxy has 32GB. And it is also 1GHX x2 :)

Monty

14

Love my motorola Xoom.Always wanted an ipad.Not now as the motorola Xoom is fantastic and would be lost without the abode flasher app which the ipad does not have.

Yo_Ipitydafool

15

I had the Ipad 2 for a few months before it got stolen bought the 32g for $600.00 at Walmart, I went back to buy a Motorola Xoom but very techie & knowledgeable staff told me to get the Acer Iconia 16g for $400.00 & I like the Acer better. Acer advantages: cheaper, larger 10.1 inch screen compared to 9.7, you can add 16g or 32g memory card only around $50.00 on Amazon, the processing speed is much faster than Ipad2, well built aluminum case, USB port, dual speakers, plays Flash! Disadvantages: ipad2 graphics is a little sharper, the camera/video is better on Ipad2, the music player on Ipad2 is clearer & noticeably louder. What I really like about Acer is it does not have that incredibly annoying Apple spellcheck feature! Basically Motorola & Acer identical in all aspects except Motorola is $100.00 more expensive but you do get built in 32g & Acer only has Wi-Fi version.

Comments are now closed.

Latest News Articles

Most Popular Articles

Follow Us

GGG Evaluation Team

Kathy Cassidy

STYLISTIC Q702

First impression on unpacking the Q702 test unit was the solid feel and clean, minimalist styling.

Anthony Grifoni

STYLISTIC Q572

For work use, Microsoft Word and Excel programs pre-installed on the device are adequate for preparing short documents.

Steph Mundell

LIFEBOOK UH574

The Fujitsu LifeBook UH574 allowed for great mobility without being obnoxiously heavy or clunky. Its twelve hours of battery life did not disappoint.

Andrew Mitsi

STYLISTIC Q702

The screen was particularly good. It is bright and visible from most angles, however heat is an issue, particularly around the Windows button on the front, and on the back where the battery housing is located.

Simon Harriott

STYLISTIC Q702

My first impression after unboxing the Q702 is that it is a nice looking unit. Styling is somewhat minimalist but very effective. The tablet part, once detached, has a nice weight, and no buttons or switches are located in awkward or intrusive positions.

Resources

Best Deals on GoodGearGuide

Latest Jobs

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?